Sotw Tab Which do you like?

[Mich 0]

Since points are being awarded for SOTW winners, no tab is being offered; so I made one of my own. Which do you like? The png was created in Paint Shop Pro and the animation in JASC Animation Shop 3.04.

 

1.

 

2.

[Albus Dumbledore 0]

i like the animated one most of all.congrats on winning

[truefusion 3]

Not bad. I voted for the non-animated one. The star might get too distracting. But i think it could use more padding.

[Plenoptic 0]

I think they are both nice and you could use both but I would use the start animation because it catches your eye and you should let everyone know you won the SOTW.

[savge17 0]

I really like the way it looks. Keep up the good work.!

[itsmyard 0]

hmm i voted for non-animated cause it takes longer too load and irratating too but good job

[Dawiss 0]

I woted for non animated.. because it gets a bit annoyng if it moves all the time the same way ...

[Mich 0]

Thanks everybody for your input. I have chosen the non-animated tab. I agree with the annoyance of motion, especially since my sig also rotates. Too much action is really annoying.

[TypoMage 0]

Well I think it is better animated. Well the other one is ok. But animated is definitly better. So keep up the good work. I am trying to make sigs not having any luck with it.

[delivi 0]

First of all congrats for winning the SOTW#45. I like the first Non-Animated Sign because, the Star animation in the 2nd Sign makes it not clearly visible and also takes time to load.