Honesty Rocks! truth rules.

Pics for my sig rate them....

HOME      >>       Graphics, Design & Animation

odomike

i have just made these 2 graphics designs and dont really know which one to use for my sig..so you guys should pls help me choose the better one to use.

 

Posted Image

 

Posted Image

 

thanks :D

Any form of critisism is welcome


Florisjuh

They look very good, I like the 2nd one more then the 1st cause 2nd one has a border... I give the 1sy an 8 and the 2nd a 9


odomike

thanks Florisjuh. good to know that my works arent that bad. still waiting for more comments about the graphics


hatebreed

i like 1st more...but you should put some cool background istead od black-white gradient2nd is so....how to say...maybe cheap...too much ordinary, i dont know...1st = 82nd = 8


Bash

the text on teh first one is awesome, if u could incorporate that to a better background i think it would be much better. you just need to learn how to make backgrounds that are more modern instead of the old/bunissiness style ones.. :D


odomike

thanks bash. been doing some practice with Adobe PS and the like. i hope to be better with graphics designing and the lot soon.Thanks too hatebreed


blia

prefer the 2nd 1..


ill

i think you should mix both graphics.add the first one's text to the second one's background and add "rule or be ruled" to it and make the border a different color. :D i think it should look really good


odomike

you got a good eye for a nice graphics design ill. i will implement your suggestion and see what it will look like. thanks


wassie

sorry to say this,but i dont like your sigs,there just so... easy.let me look:just go filter-render-cloudsthen chrome,add a border,some textand done :Sto easy...


Shackman

ya..its abit too simple.Your words are not striking enough too. You should do something to make your words(your nickname in this case) stand out form the background.Your border is a little to thick and your sig shape should be more rectangle.


qingtian

I like the 1st one better... but I think it should have a border.. I rate it 7/10 the 2nd one I don't really like cuz I think the borders too big I rate it 5/10


odomike

ok guys...i will make new ones and show to you guys. i will try to make them look much better than these ones you are seeing here.soon enough you will be seeing them.Stay cool guys


champagne

I like first one better, although there's still something missing, which I don't know what exactly that is....Anyway, keep going! :D


odomike

what exactly do you think is wrong with it? telling me this will help me improve in my graphics designing ability


champagne

what exactly do you think is wrong with it? telling me this will help me improve in my graphics designing ability

First, I have to let you know.....

Sometimes, it's just about personal taste, nothing to do with GOOD or BAD.

If this logo is for your own, which is not realated to money, then, I don't think you need to care about what other people might feel.

I think it's important to do something you really like once in a while.

 

Also, a good design doesn't always have to be complicated, sometimes it's better when it's simple, as long as you have delievered the right message efficiently. :D

 

However, it's always nice to hear the others' opinions about your design. :D

 

My opinion to the first one:

I prefer the object at front look more softly. It seems a little bit......HARD. :D


ICE-XG

how do u guys creat ur own sig.


odomike

how do u guys creat ur own sig.

goto my controls at the top of every Xisto forum page. click on it and you will see a list of your controls on the left of the page. click on EDIT SIGNATURE and you can add any TEXT or PIC to your sig (signature).your pic cannot just diplay unless you put a link to it. if you dont know how to do that, you can use image hosting and Image Shack is a very good example. design your sig and upload to their server. copy the link they will give you and paste it in your sig edit box and your sig (pic) will start displaying under every post you post.
BTW, thank you champagne for the advice. it is well taken.

dontmaimyourself

Well Im sure i,ve already posted here but I cant find it so, I like the second one, your current sig, its cool especially the 'rule or be ruled', I chose rule btw, also the background thats nice I do think the borders a bit much tho mate. The first one is nice too, nice work, cool sigs. wish I was that good at creating graphics. :(


odomike

Well Im sure i,ve already posted here but I cant find it so, I like the second one, your current sig, its cool especially the 'rule or be ruled', I chose rule btw, also the background thats nice I do think the borders a bit much tho mate. The first one is nice too, nice work, cool sigs. wish I was that good at creating graphics.  :(

lolz...it is good you chose RULE instead of to be ruled. Thanks Dontmaimyourself for your review. Actually, I dont take myself to be that good in graphic designing. I know there are guys who are much better than I in graphic desingning. I am just trying my best and that was the result for now. I am still trying to perfect in my graphic designing abilities.
Thanks once again Dontmaim :(:(


Pages :-

Page 1Page 2